I Was Thinking … About the Whole Housing Picture

Today’s decisions create the future community.

Share
I Was Thinking … About the Whole Housing Picture
Scott Rogers is thinking by the water.

The disagreement between Affordable Hometown Port Townsend and the City of Port Townsend has moved beyond arguments about a plan. Habitat for Humanity has paused its planned 11-home Carter Commons project, and OlyCAP has stopped work on plans to replace its Haines Street Cottages with affordable apartments. Both cited uncertainty about the zoning rules. The city is seeking a court order to pause the state board’s ruling, with a hearing scheduled for Nov. 6.

For the people waiting for those homes, this has consequences.

I was thinking about how quickly a community discussion can become a fight over individual pieces of a much larger picture. Sixplexes. Building heights. Parking. Neighborhood character. Each matters. But when each one becomes its own battle, how does the public decide whether the overall direction makes sense?

I wonder how much of this is driven by fear.

Some people fear losing the town they love. Others fear they will never be able to afford to live here. Business owners wonder where their employees will live. Parents wonder whether their children will have a future here. People on fixed incomes wonder what the next tax or utility increase will do to their budget.

Those concerns are all part of the same conversation.

Just because a thing is allowed does not mean it will be built. Allowing an apartment building does not produce financing, pay for construction or connect the sewer. The city’s own plan acknowledges that infrastructure gaps and costs stand in the way of housing.

But allowing more housing does raise a fair question: if it gets built, are we ready?

Jefferson County’s housing analysis calls for 4,119 additional homes countywide over the 2020-2045 planning period. That includes 1,648 in Port Townsend, another 1,648 in the Irondale-Port Hadlock urban growth area, and 823 elsewhere in the county. So the plan already gives Port Hadlock and Irondale as large a housing role as Port Townsend.

Those numbers deserve a plain explanation. They are not all homes for people moving here. Housing planning also needs to account for people who already live here and cannot find suitable housing. Nor do those numbers mean every property will suddenly be developed to its maximum.

Still, more homes mean demands on roads, water, sewer and public services. We should understand those demands before we find ourselves trying to catch up.

Anyone who drives through Four Corners or between Port Townsend and Chimacum understands why transportation belongs in this discussion. Where will people work? Where will they shop? Will they need to drive into Port Townsend every day? What happens when an accident or road closure disrupts the usual route?

There are studies. The county’s 2026 transportation analysis looks at future traffic and possible improvements. It identifies, for example, a future congestion problem at Chimacum Road and State Highway 19 and evaluates how a roundabout could help.

What I would like to see is those studies brought together in a way the rest of us can use.

Show us where the homes are expected. Show us what the roads and utilities can handle. Explain which improvements are needed, when they are needed, what they cost and who pays. Explain what happens if the money does not arrive.

And let’s look beyond the city limits.

Could we do a better job of sharing housing, jobs and services among the communities from Port Townsend through Port Hadlock and toward Chimacum? The Port Hadlock sewer system is now operating, opening opportunities where service is available. How do we build on that investment?

Putting homes farther outside Port Townsend will not solve much if everyone still has to drive into town for work and daily needs. A regional approach needs places to work, shop and gather, along with homes. It needs to respect the farms, natural areas and differences between our communities.

We also need to understand the cost of standing still. What happens when a teacher cannot find a home, a business cannot hire a worker, or a longtime resident has to leave? And what happens to existing residents’ bills if too few households are left sharing the cost of maintaining our infrastructure?

I am not expecting a guarantee about the next 20 years. I am asking for an understandable picture of where we are going and how we expect to make it work.

Then let the public base its support on that whole picture. Give people enough information to weigh the benefits, costs and trade-offs together.

We have spent plenty of time arguing over the flashpoints. I would like us to spend more time helping people understand the community those decisions will create.