Op-Ed: A Community Lit on Fire
Director of Well-Organized, Cameron Jones, writes about the Comprehensive Plan.
By Cameron Jones
I've been involved in Port Townsend's Comprehensive Plan update since 2025, and I want to share my thoughts as a community organizer who's followed both the planning process and the ongoing litigation brought by “Affordable Hometown Port Townsend” (AHPT). The latest chapter in this saga unfolded at the November 16 City Council meeting.
During public comment, Devin G. stated: “When affluent homeowners dictate what housing is allowed in their neighborhoods, they're effectively deciding who gets to live in Port Townsend and who doesn't.”
I agree with Devin. This is a big part of why I do the work I do.
I've lived in Port Townsend for nearly 30 years and have been a persistent critic of the City, especially around community engagement. As a director of Well-Organized Jefferson County, I spent nearly a year working with Engage Jefferson County to bring historically marginalized folks into the Comprehensive Plan process, including low-income folks, immigrants, youth and Black and brown community members.
The process wasn't perfect, but it was the most meaningful community engagement effort I've experienced here. Much of the feedback during those conversations supported increased housing density. We identified shortcomings and understood that our advocacy would continue beyond the plan's adoption.
Then came AHPT's legal challenge.
Central to AHPT's argument is its claim to be fighting for affordable housing. The group argues that increased density will encourage expensive development, displace existing households and strain infrastructure without providing housing that lower-income folks can afford.
But who is behind AHPT? According to reporting in the Beacon, the four homeowners behind the challenge—John Watts, John Capps, Todd McGuire and Mary McCurdy—hold properties collectively valued at more than $6.7 million.
This reflects the power dynamics Devin described. Wealthy homeowners have the resources to challenge public decisions through litigation, while working-class folks, immigrants and Black and brown communities struggle to be heard. Those with the most power can influence decisions whose consequences fall on those with the least.
At the November 16 meeting, AHPT President John Watts maintained that the challenge concerned the last-minute R-II amendment, not development in R-III or R-IV. He said AHPT never sought restrictions affecting those other zones.
Why does that matter?
Earlier that evening, Habitat for Humanity Executive Director Jamie Maciejewski explained that Habitat primarily builds in R-III and R-IV, where uncertainty over the City's interpretation of the GMHB's invalidity order had caused Habitat to pause planning for future neighborhoods.
Watts maintained that these impacts weren't what AHPT requested. Yet AHPT's February 20 petition raised 13 issues, including challenges to the City's transportation plan, infrastructure financing, development concurrency requirements and public participation throughout the Comprehensive Plan update. Those concerns go well beyond the R-II amendment.
This being the case, it's no wonder Councilmember David Faber said he was "absolutely mystified," asking, "Why did they appeal those other things if they're only concerned about that one discrete issue?"
Mayor Amy Howard went a step further, characterizing Watts's framing as "disingenuous."
The City's website contains AHPT's original petition, the Growth Management Hearings Board (GMHB) decision and months of correspondence between the attorneys. I've reviewed these records and encourage folks to do the same. One finding from the GMHB's August 19 decision that AHPT seems to omit from its public narrative concerns its repeated claims about density and affordability. The Board stated:
"Petitioner's repeated characterization of the City's upzone as creating an incentive for more expensive development that will not serve all economic segments has not been proven by the Petitioner, nor is it borne out in this record."
The Board required the City to address deficiencies in its planning, but it did not substantiate AHPT's claim that upzoning would encourage more expensive development at the expense of affordability.
And the correspondence between the attorneys reveals another side of this dispute.
Here's the timeline: The City initiated settlement outreach in March and offered a counterproposal in April that included affordable housing studies, anti-displacement work and community engagement. The parties continued exchanging proposals through August and September, with AHPT's attorney, Bryan Telegin, attaching conditions to cooperation over the moratorium, compliance and settlement.
The City adopted an R-II moratorium in August and pursued compliance alongside its judicial appeal. Yet on November 16, Watts conditioned AHPT's support for a joint stay on the City withdrawing that appeal. City Attorney Austin Watkins explained that the appeal needed to remain active for the proposed stay, something he had communicated to Telegin in August.
That same evening, Council authorized $300,000 for remand work, including housing analysis and public engagement. Faber urged AHPT: "Please work with us, and do not try and dictate outcomes."
That's the legal record. But what has AHPT been telling the community?
I've been receiving emails from Accountable PT, a separate but closely connected group led by Judy Krebs, who communicates directly with AHPT President John Watts. Comparing the narrative she's been sharing with folks against the documented legal record has been eye-opening.
In September, Krebs acknowledged that the City had agreed to talks with AHPT and that both parties were exploring a joint stay. Yet in the same email, she asserted that "the only basis for the City's appeal to superior court and motion for a stay before the GMHB" was that City officials "do not want to go back to the public and have a real conversation about planned density, non-displacement and affordable housing."
This was months after the City's April counteroffer proposing additional housing studies, anti-displacement measures, and public engagement.
On November 15, the day before Council's meeting, Krebs wrote: "Why is the City causing such dismay amongst Habitat for Humanity and OlyCap when it could be cleaning up the mess it made?" She also asserted that "the City continues to misdirect the public into believing that AHPT is the cause of the lack of clarity in the City's zoning regulations."
These statements place responsibility on the City while leaving out AHPT's broader petition, the conditions it has placed on cooperation, and the City's documented efforts to address the Board's findings.
At the November 16 meeting, Councilmember Owen Rowe challenged a similar claim from AHPT's John Capps that the City was appealing to avoid complying with the GMHB decision. Rowe pointed to the City's ongoing compliance work and called the assertion disinformation.
Councilmember Fred Obee then said, "It really doesn't matter what people said before, what the issues were previously," urging Council to focus on solutions.
But here's the problem: what was said before is still being said now and it has impact.
Even as I'm writing this, it's 1 a.m. on November 17, and another Accountable PT email from Judy Krebs arrives. She accuses Council of rejecting AHPT's "olive branch," despite Watkins having clearly explained why the conditions attached to Watts's offer were unacceptable.
She goes on to say:
"The fact is the City likes the lack of clarity so it can manufacture this affordable housing crisis and blame AHPT for it."
The real fact is, without AHPT's legal challenge, we wouldn't be in this situation. Their lawsuit led to the invalidity order, the uncertainty facing affordable housing providers and the negotiations now consuming the City's time and resources. Yet Krebs continues to place the responsibility on the City.
For a group calling itself Accountable PT, it remains remarkably unaccountable for its own actions.
How can we build common ground with a group that refuses to take accountability for the consequences of its own actions, continues to deflect blame onto the City and claims to speak for an entire community?
And this is why I disagree with Councilmember Fred Obee's framing of these exchanges as bickering over the past. This isn't the past. It's happening right now.
And it's reaching a wider audience. In her November 15 email, Krebs shared that she'd become a columnist for the Port Townsend Leader and had appeared on its inaugural podcast discussing Accountable PT. We're not just talking about claims circulating in an email list anymore. These narratives are gaining a larger platform in our local media.
And this brings me back to whose voices count.
AHPT has the resources and legal representation to challenge the Comprehensive Plan. But that doesn't give a handful of litigants the authority to determine the outcomes of community engagement or speak for everyone affected by our housing crisis.
Devin didn't just speak for himself on November 16. He submitted a petition signed by more than 100 folks who live or work in Port Townsend, stating that AHPT does not represent them.
The City and AHPT may need to negotiate a legal path forward. But those negotiations cannot replace the voices of folks who participated in the original planning process, many of whom have historically been excluded from decisions shaping our community.
Around 10:30 that night, towards the end of the meeting, Mayor Amy Howard made one of the most poignant comments of the meeting. Reflecting on the work done to engage historically marginalized communities during the Comprehensive Plan update, she warned:
"If we discount their opinions now, if we don't re-engage them in this process, we are not building trust; we are lighting it on fire."
While I wholeheartedly agree with Mayor Howard's sentiment, I fear this is already a community lit on fire. And it's a fire fueled by misinformation, entitlement and privilege.
August 19th GMHB Final Decision
March 18th AHPT Settlement Offer
April 10 City's Settlement Counter Offer
August 26th Telegin Law Letter